Comparing the Top Homeschool Math Curricula: What We Tried and Why We Switched
We have used five different math curricula across three children. Here is an honest comparison of the most popular options, who each works best for, and the one we keep coming back to.
A little note: Some links in this post are affiliate links. If you click through and buy something, we earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. We only ever link to things we would genuinely recommend to a friend.
We switched math curricula three times in our first four years of homeschooling.
The first switch was because my son was bored. The second was because my daughter was frustrated. The third was because I realized I had been choosing curriculum based on reviews from families with different children than mine.
What I know now that I did not know then: the curriculum is less important than the fit. The right curriculum for your child is the one that produces progress without daily tears. That is it. Everything else is secondary.
Here is what we found in the curricula we actually used.
Math-U-See
Philosophy: Mastery-based. One concept is introduced and practiced until it is mastered before moving on. Uses manipulative blocks to build conceptual understanding.
Best for: Children who need concrete, visual demonstration before abstraction. Children who struggle with traditional curriculum pacing. Families who want clear scope and sequence.
Watch out for: Children who need more spiral review (returning to old concepts regularly) can struggle because Math-U-See moves on and rarely comes back. Some children also outgrow the manipulatives faster than the program accounts for.
Our experience: My younger daughter used this from K-4. The blocks were transformative for her. She physically built what division meant before she ever wrote a division problem.
Singapore Math
Philosophy: Conceptual depth through visual models (bar modeling), mental math strategies, and careful sequencing. Originally developed for Singapore's nationally excellent math education.
Best for: Children who are strong visual learners and respond well to challenging problem-solving. Families who want rigorous math with real conceptual depth.
Watch out for: The word problems are genuinely hard. Children who are math-anxious may find this curriculum intimidating at the transition from arithmetic to multi-step problem solving. The bar modeling method requires parent buy-in — you have to understand it yourself to teach it well.
Our experience: My oldest, who loves math, used Singapore from grade 3 through middle school. The bar modeling approach produced mental math ability I had not seen from any other curriculum.
Saxon Math
Philosophy: Incremental development with heavy spiral review. Every lesson introduces a small amount of new material and reviews everything learned before it.
Best for: Children who need constant repetition to retain information. Children who have gaps from previous curriculum. Families who want a complete, scripted, independent program.
Watch out for: The repetition that helps some children drive others crazy. Saxon is long. A full Saxon lesson takes significantly more time than most competing curricula. Gifted math students may find the pacing extremely slow.
Our experience: We used Saxon briefly with my son and switched after two months. For him, the spiral repetition felt punishing. He already knew it. For a different child — one who genuinely needs more repetition — Saxon would have been exactly right.
RightStart Mathematics
Philosophy: Abacus-based, game-heavy, designed to build deep number sense. Every concept is introduced with the AL abacus and games before moving to paper.
Best for: Young children and children who struggle with number sense. Children who learn better through play. Families who want to be actively involved in every lesson.
Watch out for: RightStart requires the parent to be present and engaged for every lesson. It is not an independent curriculum. It is also more expensive than most alternatives. The time investment is significant.
Our experience: Best math curriculum we ever used for early childhood. The abacus-based approach produced mathematical intuition in my youngest that drill-based programs could not have created.
The Question to Ask Before Buying
Before purchasing any math curriculum, answer three questions:
Is my child a procedural or conceptual learner? Procedural learners (who are good at following steps) can succeed with almost any curriculum. Conceptual learners (who need to understand why) do better with Singapore, RightStart, or Math-U-See.
Does my child need mastery or spiral? Mastery curricula (Math-U-See) move on when a concept is solid. Spiral curricula (Saxon) return to everything constantly.
How much parent involvement can I commit to? Some curricula are nearly independent (Saxon). Others require the parent as active teacher every day (RightStart, Singapore's Standards Edition).
The best math curriculum is the one your child uses without a battle. Start with what seems most likely to fit, and do not be afraid to switch if the fit is wrong. One semester of the wrong curriculum is not going to define your child's mathematical future. Choosing based on your child's actual needs, rather than a reviewer's recommendation, is the most important math decision you will make.
Written by
The High Vibe Homeschool Team
We are a homeschool family that has been doing this for seven years across three kids. We write about what we have actually tried, what failed, what surprised us, and what we would do again. No credentials. Just lived experience.
ENJOYED THIS ARTICLE?
Get more like it every week
Real homeschool life, in your inbox.
Keep Reading
More in Curriculum
CurriculumMath Games That Make Numbers Come Alive (Even for the Kid Who Hates Math)
My son cried at math worksheets for two years. Then we found games. Here are the ones that changed everything — no flashcards required.
CurriculumLiving Books: What They Are and How to Find Them
Charlotte Mason's term for books that feel alive. Here's what makes a book 'living,' why it matters, and a list of the ones that have done the most for our homeschool.
CurriculumTeaching Writing at Home (When You Don't Feel Like a Writing Teacher)
Writing is the subject most homeschool parents fear most. Here's how we finally made it work — and the approach that produces the most growth for the least friction.